Borough of Manhattan Community College (BMCC) is the largest community college in the City University of New York system with 27,000 degree-seeking students but with a three-year graduation rate of 22%. Our catalytic grant doubled the size of BMCC’s IMPACT Peer Mentoring program which recruits upperclassmen to serve as peer mentors for first-semester students. Mentors meet with mentees in person once a week and maintain regular contact several times a week to provide support in five areas: role-modeling, community building, success coaching, campus resources, and advocacy. Assessments conducted by BMCC’s Office of Institutional Effectiveness and Analytics show that the IMPACT Peer Mentoring program produces consistently higher retention and graduation rates for mentors and mentees as compared with similarly situated students not affiliated with these programs. IMPACT mentees had a three-year graduation rate nearly 60% higher than similar students not in the mentorship program as well as higher credit accumulation numbers in each semester tracked before graduation.